Modify Custody Orders in Wisconsin

When circumstances change, get the court to modify the original custody order

Custody Modification in Wisconsin

Life is pretty unpredictable and circumstances will inevitably change. It's for this very reason that the court can modify a custody order. Keep in mind that the court is unlikely to change your custody order “just because.” You'll have to make a strong case that circumstances directly affecting the child have considerably changed. 

When can Child Custody be modified in WI?

Child custody agreements, or placement, in Wisconsin should be in the best interest of the child. If significant changes affect the welfare of a child involved in a placement agreement, the courts may choose to enforce a court order or grant a modification based on either parent's request for a modification.

Two-year judgment of Wisconsin 767.451 statute

Unless there is physical or emotional harm related to the best interest of a child(ren), Wisconsin courts cannot modify child placement within the first two years after the final judgment determining legal custody or physical placement, according to statute 767.451. The primary reason why there is such a strenuous two-year cap is to allow both parents and the child(ren) the opportunity to get used to the new arrangement.

However, with substantial evidence, a court may be willing to modify the child placement order. Examples in which the two-year permanent decision may include:

  • Substantial change of circumstances since the last order of legal custody
  • Economic circumstances change
  • Marital status of either or both parties change or is not sufficient for the child's well-being
  • Repeated and intentional failure by a parent to exercise agreed-upon physical placement agreement with the other parent
  • A parent is called in for active duty in the U.S. Armed Forces and physical placement of the parent changes (Usually the physical placement of the child before the service member's discharge or release from active duty is re-implemented.)
  • Sufficient evidence proves that the child is in physical, mental, or emotional danger with his or her current physical placement
  • One parent is killed or dies of natural causes
  • One parent commits a first-degree intentional homicide, second-degree intentional homicide, harms or kills the other parent (Even if the trial is in the appeal stages, until the conviction is reversed, vacated, or set aside, the placement changes may still stand.)
  • A stepparent in which the child the child is living with has a criminal record and/or a track record of abuse or neglect.

To make a strong case, it's important to understand the types of circumstances the court considers when hearing a petition to modify an order.

What WILL NOT Work in Court

Before you spend the time and resources attempting to modify child custody, it's important to understand the following common examples are unlikely to change a custody order:

  • Failure to allow visitation to the noncustodial If you are not receiving visitation rights that were agreed upon in the original custody hearing, courts can reinforce the original agreement. But the court will not change the custody agreement for this reason.
  • Change of circumstances for the noncustodial Just because your circumstances have improved, it hasn't changed the well-being of the child and the circumstances surrounding the custodial parent are unchanged.
  • Being behind in child support payments could lead to the court taking that into consideration when considering child custody modification in the other parent's favor.
  • If the custodial parent has legally moved the child to another state and hasn't violated custody agreements, the court won't factor it into your custody change case.

Alternate options before implementing new child placement order

There are circumstances in which it is highly recommended to try to self-regulate child placement arrangements. For example, if a parent's work hours change, working together to sort out temporary hours may be beneficial. However, if a situation such as this leads to either parent purposely decreasing the hours of the other parent's opportunity to be with the child, filing a motion with the court requesting a modification/review for child placement may be the only option. Scheduling changes may affect the child's ability to get to school on time or negatively affect the child's state of mind with either or both parents.

Wisconsin courts will take these kinds of factors into consideration, including within the two-year trial period. Even in a prenuptial agreement, the arrangements that parents made may be modified by a family court judge to benefit the safety and rights of the child, not the parents. One of the primary reasons for this, in addition to the mental and physical health of the child, is the original arrangements when the prenuptial agreement was signed may not realistically fit current circumstances.

Book a Consult
Call for Immediate Assistance
(262) 221-8123
or fill out the form below to book a consult.

Types of Child Custody in Wisconsin

Other Child Custody Options

Alternating Custody

Sometimes referred to as divided custody, alternating custody occurs when the child lives with one parent for a semester or several months of a year and then spends time living with the other parent for another extended period of time. The length of stay with each parent is not necessarily proportionate or relative to how long the child previously spent with the other parent.

During these stays, the parent with whom the child is currently living with is the provider for that child and oversees all responsibility of the child.

Shared Custody

Shared custody is a pretty common custody model. It occurs when the child is with one parent for a set amount of time and then with the other parent for a similar amount of time.

Unlike alternating custody, both parents the responsibilities of the child. So even if the child is not presently spending time with you, your rights as a parent are never minimized or taken away from you.

Bird's Nest Custody

Bird's nest custody removes the burden of going from one parents home to the other. In this custody setting, the parent's share a residency where the child will always reside. The parents then alternate who stays at that residence and when.

This custody option provides stability for the child and allows them to have the feeling of always having a home regardless of which parent is staying there with them at the time.

Get Answers from Top Rated Attorneys

meet with a divorce attorney and get divorce advice

Get Legal Advice

Sit down with a top rated local attorney and discuss your case. The stress of the unknown can be resolved with just a phone call or a few clicks.

get divorce advice during divorce seminar

Attend a Seminar

Thinking about moving forward with a divorce or separation? Not sure where to start? Get a clear picture of your options by attending a seminar.

What our Clients are Saying

"This past fall, I filed for divorce. My husband and I were in a situation where neither of us really needed a lawyer to sort things out, so I decided to file pro se. I was concerned about making a mistake in the paperwork and delaying the final separation, so I called Sterling Law. Attorney Festerling agreed to work w/me on a "consult only" basis, meaning she would answer my questions and review my documents, charging only for the time spent on those things. There would be no big legal fees incurred for her presence in court or for her time in filling out documents that I was capable of handling myself. She was kind and helpful, and our case went through without a hitch. The overall outlay was very reasonable. I was very happy with the help I received and felt confident going to the court date, knowing all our ducks were in a row. It was as good as an experience like this can be."

Beth E.

Full Google+ Review

Sterling Law Offices, S.C.
Average Rating

4.4 Out of 5
Based on 558 Reviews
star ratingstar ratingstar ratingstar ratinginterface
See all Reviews

We are Always Here to Help

divorce law firm member Kelley Shaw

Kelley S.

Client Advocate

divorce law firm paralegal Nancy Stanton

Nancy S.


Family Law Firm Team Member Lynne

Lynne B.

Client Advocate

Have a question? Get in touch today.

Schedule an Attorney Consult!

Sterling Law Offices WISN A-List Finalists - Best Divorce Lawyers
BBB Rated Sterling Law Offices - Top divorce lawyer
SuperLawyers Sterling Law Offices - Top divorce attorney
AVVO Rated Sterling Law Offices - Best divorce attorneys
Call: (262) 221-8123